Penance : Fulfillment of Our Obligation to Express Moral Wrath

This post is a criticism and development of my previous two posts on penance.
February 16, 2015: Penance: Pain as a Scapegoat Which Carries Away Moral Evil
February 24, 2015:Penance: Guilt, Shame, Self-Loathing as Penitential Pain

In those posts, I interpreted penance as self inflicted pain to make up for and restore oneself after commission of a moral wrong. An act of masturbation was the example of an immoral act so that there would be no issues of compensating other people. Four dimensions of making up for and restoring were noted. Restitution was inflicting a pain to pay for an immorally attained satisfaction. This could be a simple fast of skipping a meal. Rehabilitation was inflicting pain so that by becoming accustomed to enduring dissatisfaction aesonould be less likely to subcumb to temptations to seek immoral satisfactions.Again a simple fast could be an example of penance. Deterrence was inflicting pain with a threat to inflict it again if we pursued the immoral satisfaction. Taking a cold shower with threats of subsequent cold showers is an example of a deterring penance. My focus was on the retributive dimension of penance. Retribution is the most difficult dimension for which to articulate a motivation even if in some people the need for it is strongly felt.

In retribution we inflict a pain to represent to ourselves our moral evil, i.e., breaking a moral law, as physical or mental damage. This physical or mental damage intentionally connected with the moral damage can be called punishment. Punishment is always a physical or mental pain. Punishment is imposed for moral reasons but the punishment itself is factual (empirical) not moral. Penance is self-inflicted punishment.With recovery from the connected factual damage the moral damage is cleansed or healed. The factual damage becomes a “scapegoat” which carries away the moral damage.

Perhaps my account of retributive penance accounts for why some, or even many, people do punish themselves for immoral behavior with a hard to articulate sense that it makes them clean or healthy again. But an account of why some people punish themselves does not justify their doing so and certainly does not give support to a claim that this type of retributive punishment is what we ought to do.. Now my goal is to make a case that we ought to perform retributive penance.

Why ought connect factual damage with moral damage by inflicting factual damage on an offender because of his moral damage? If we do not accept a prescription for conduct as a command coming from ourselves in which we both think and feel that factual damage be imposed on violators we do not accept it as a moral law. Thinking and feeling that factual damage be imposed on violators simply because they violated a moral law is moral wrath. Genuine acceptance of what we think ought to be requires internalizing the prescription. Internalizing a prescription requires feeling that it ought to be followed because what it commands is right. This feeling that it ought to be followed because it is right has as a complementary feeling a sense that a violator ought to be damaged in some factual way simply because he did not act as he ought. Acting on this moral wrath is retribution. In retribution we do not seek to accomplish anything by imposition of the damage beyond striking back after violation of the law. To be sure, as noted above, in inflicting damage after a violation, we may hope to accomplish restitution, rehabilitation and deterrence. But retribution is simply to express the obligation to react negatively to violations of a moral law we have internalized, viz., genuinely accepted.

Penance, then, is retribution inflicted on ourselves for our own violations of morality. As the wounds from our self-inflicted moral wrath heal, we often have a sense of being healed or cleansed.

My thoughts about penance, forgiveness etc., come from my emphasis on sexual immorality as producing moral harm in my book Confronting Sexual Nihilism .
My book Confronting Sexual Nihilism: Traditional Sexual Morality as an Antidote to Nihilism was released by Tate Publishing on March 11, 2014. See Book Web Page for information about the book. The publisher’s listed price is $26.99. Printed copies can be purchased here by credit card for $12.99, plus $3.71 for shipping and handling.





To purchase the printed book by check, send check of $16.70 per copy. Send to:
Charles F. Kielkopf
45 W. Kenworth Rd.
Columbus, Ohio 43214
Include your shipping address.

18,610 thoughts on “Penance : Fulfillment of Our Obligation to Express Moral Wrath

  1. Pingback: net
  2. Pingback: wow gold
  3. Pingback: nike shoes air max
  4. Pingback: cheap asics
  5. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  6. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  7. Pingback: learn more here
  8. Pingback: asic gel nimbus 12
  9. Pingback: cheap asics
  10. Pingback: cheap asics
  11. Pingback: mens asics
  12. Pingback: cheap asics
  13. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  14. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  15. Pingback: mens asics
  16. Pingback: mens asics
  17. Pingback: cheap asics
  18. Pingback: wow gold
  19. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  20. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  21. Pingback: asics kayano 19
  22. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  23. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  24. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  25. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  26. Pingback: rent car
  27. Pingback: micro loans
  28. Pingback: mens asics
  29. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  30. Pingback: mortgage broker
  31. Pingback: junking a car
  32. Pingback: mens asics
  33. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  34. Pingback: mens asics
  35. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  36. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  37. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  38. Pingback: here
  39. Pingback: cheap asics
  40. Pingback: asics kayano 19
  41. Pingback: mens asics
  42. Pingback: performance chip
  43. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  44. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  45. Pingback: electronic module
  46. Pingback: asics kayano 19
  47. Pingback: here
  48. Pingback: here
  49. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  50. Pingback: cheap asics
  51. Pingback: cheap asics
  52. Pingback: cheap asics
  53. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  54. Pingback: cheap asics
  55. Pingback: office roshe run
  56. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  57. Pingback: electronic module
  58. Pingback: nike tn pas cher
  59. Pingback: ray ban pas cher
  60. Pingback: ecu motor
  61. Pingback: here
  62. Pingback: here
  63. Pingback: here
  64. Pingback: here
  65. Pingback: here
  66. Pingback: here
  67. Pingback: here
  68. Pingback: here
  69. Pingback: here
  70. Pingback: here
  71. Pingback: mens asics
  72. Pingback: here
  73. Pingback: here
  74. Pingback: here
  75. Pingback: here
  76. Pingback: here
  77. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  78. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  79. Pingback: here
  80. Pingback: here
  81. Pingback: here
  82. Pingback: here
  83. Pingback: asic gel nimbus
  84. Pingback: here
  85. Pingback: here
  86. Pingback: here
  87. Pingback: here
  88. Pingback: here
  89. Pingback: here
  90. Pingback: here
  91. Pingback: here
  92. Pingback: here
  93. Pingback: here
  94. Pingback: here
  95. Pingback: here
  96. Pingback: here
  97. Pingback: here
  98. Pingback: here
  99. Pingback: here
  100. Pingback: here
  101. Pingback: here
  102. Pingback: here
  103. Pingback: here
  104. Pingback: here
  105. Pingback: here
  106. Pingback: here
  107. Pingback: here
  108. Pingback: mens asics
  109. Pingback: here
  110. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  111. Pingback: korean boys name
  112. Pingback: here
  113. Pingback: here
  114. Pingback: here
  115. Pingback: cheap asics
  116. Pingback: wow gold
  117. Pingback: here
  118. Pingback: mens asics gt 2000
  119. Pingback: here
  120. Pingback: here
  121. Pingback: here
  122. Pingback: here
  123. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  124. Pingback: here
  125. Pingback: here
  126. Pingback: here
  127. Pingback: black asics
  128. Pingback: program diet cepat
  129. Pingback: here
  130. Pingback: here
  131. Pingback: here
  132. Pingback: here
  133. Pingback: here
  134. Pingback: here
  135. Pingback: here
  136. Pingback: here
  137. Pingback: here
  138. Pingback: here
  139. Pingback: here
  140. Pingback: here
  141. Pingback: asics resolution
  142. Pingback: here
  143. Pingback: here
  144. Pingback: here
  145. Pingback: here
  146. Pingback: here
  147. Pingback: cheap asics
  148. Pingback: here
  149. Pingback: here
  150. Pingback: mens asics
  151. Pingback: asics kayano 19
  152. Pingback: here
  153. Pingback: here
  154. Pingback: here
  155. Pingback: here
  156. Pingback: here
  157. Pingback: here
  158. Pingback: here
  159. Pingback: here
  160. Pingback: here
  161. Pingback: here
  162. Pingback: here
  163. Pingback: here
  164. Pingback: here
  165. Pingback: here
  166. Pingback: here
  167. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  168. Pingback: here
  169. Pingback: here
  170. Pingback: here
  171. Pingback: here
  172. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  173. Pingback: here
  174. Pingback: here
  175. Pingback: here
  176. Pingback: here
  177. Pingback: here
  178. Pingback: langkah diet sehat
  179. Pingback: here
  180. Pingback: here
  181. Pingback: here
  182. Pingback: asics kayano 19
  183. Pingback: here
  184. Pingback: here
  185. Pingback: here
  186. Pingback: here
  187. Pingback: here
  188. Pingback: here
  189. Pingback: here
  190. Pingback: here
  191. Pingback: here
  192. Pingback: here
  193. Pingback: here
  194. Pingback: here
  195. Pingback: here
  196. Pingback: here
  197. Pingback: here
  198. Pingback: here
  199. Pingback: here
  200. Pingback: here
  201. Pingback: here
  202. Pingback: here
  203. Pingback: here
  204. Pingback: here
  205. Pingback: here
  206. Pingback: here
  207. Pingback: here
  208. Pingback: here
  209. Pingback: here
  210. Pingback: here
  211. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  212. Pingback: here
  213. Pingback: here
  214. Pingback: here
  215. Pingback: here
  216. Pingback: safest wow gold
  217. Pingback: here
  218. Pingback: here
  219. Pingback: here
  220. Pingback: here
  221. Pingback: here
  222. Pingback: here
  223. Pingback: here
  224. Pingback: here
  225. Pingback: here
  226. Pingback: here
  227. Pingback: safest wow gold
  228. Pingback: here
  229. Pingback: here
  230. Pingback: here
  231. Pingback: here
  232. Pingback: vitamin d sources
  233. Pingback: here
  234. Pingback: here
  235. Pingback: here
  236. Pingback: here
  237. Pingback: here
  238. Pingback: here
  239. Pingback: here
  240. Pingback: here
  241. Pingback: here
  242. Pingback: here
  243. Pingback: here
  244. Pingback: here
  245. Pingback: here
  246. Pingback: here
  247. Pingback: here
  248. Pingback: here
  249. Pingback: here
  250. Pingback: here
  251. Pingback: here
  252. Pingback: here
  253. Pingback: here
  254. Pingback: here
  255. Pingback: here
  256. Pingback: here
  257. Pingback: here
  258. Pingback: here
  259. Pingback: here
  260. Pingback: here
  261. Pingback: here
  262. Pingback: here
  263. Pingback: here
  264. Pingback: here
  265. Pingback: here
  266. Pingback: advance loan
  267. Pingback: here
  268. Pingback: here
  269. Pingback: here
  270. Pingback: here
  271. Pingback: here
  272. Pingback: here
  273. Pingback: here
  274. Pingback: here
  275. Pingback: here
  276. Pingback: here
  277. Pingback: here
  278. Pingback: here
  279. Pingback: here
  280. Pingback: here
  281. Pingback: here
  282. Pingback: here
  283. Pingback: here
  284. Pingback: here
  285. Pingback: here
  286. Pingback: here
  287. Pingback: here
  288. Pingback: here
  289. Pingback: here
  290. Pingback: here
  291. Pingback: here
  292. Pingback: here
  293. Pingback: here
  294. Pingback: here
  295. Pingback: here
  296. Pingback: korean artist name
  297. Pingback: here
  298. Pingback: here
  299. Pingback: here
  300. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  301. Pingback: here
  302. Pingback: here
  303. Pingback: mens asics
  304. Pingback: here
  305. Pingback: here
  306. Pingback: here
  307. Pingback: here
  308. Pingback: here
  309. Pingback: here
  310. Pingback: vitamin hati
  311. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  312. Pingback: here
  313. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  314. Pingback: here
  315. Pingback: here
  316. Pingback: here
  317. Pingback: here
  318. Pingback: here
  319. Pingback: here
  320. Pingback: here
  321. Pingback: here
  322. Pingback: pelangsing badan
  323. Pingback: here
  324. Pingback: here
  325. Pingback: here
  326. Pingback: here
  327. Pingback: here
  328. Pingback: cheap asics
  329. Pingback: here
  330. Pingback: here
  331. Pingback: here
  332. Pingback: here
  333. Pingback: michael kors hobo
  334. Pingback: here
  335. Pingback: here
  336. Pingback: here
  337. Pingback: contoh ruang dapur
  338. Pingback: here
  339. Pingback: here
  340. Pingback: here
  341. Pingback: here
  342. Pingback: here
  343. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  344. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  345. Pingback: here
  346. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  347. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  348. Pingback: here
  349. Pingback: here
  350. Pingback: here
  351. Pingback: here
  352. Pingback: here
  353. Pingback: here
  354. Pingback: here
  355. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  356. Pingback: here
  357. Pingback: here
  358. Pingback: here
  359. Pingback: here
  360. Pingback: here
  361. Pingback: here
  362. Pingback: here
  363. Pingback: here
  364. Pingback: here
  365. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  366. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  367. Pingback: here
  368. Pingback: mens asics
  369. Pingback: here
  370. Pingback: here
  371. Pingback: here
  372. Pingback: here
  373. Pingback: here
  374. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  375. Pingback: here
  376. Pingback: here
  377. Pingback: asics kayano 19
  378. Pingback: nike free 5.0 v4
  379. Pingback: roshe run women
  380. Pingback: michael kors sale
  381. Pingback: nike roshe runs
  382. Pingback: nike roshe women
  383. Pingback: ray ban frames
  384. Pingback: ray ban outlet
  385. Pingback: nike free run 5.0
  386. Pingback: nike roshe women
  387. Pingback: red bottom heels
  388. Pingback: nike free run 5.0
  389. Pingback: custom roshe run
  390. Pingback: here
  391. Pingback: here
  392. Pingback: here
  393. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  394. Pingback: here
  395. Pingback: here
  396. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  397. Pingback: here
  398. Pingback: cheap asics
  399. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  400. Pingback: here
  401. Pingback: poster kesehatan
  402. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  403. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  404. Pingback: mens asics
  405. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  406. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  407. Pingback: maillot italie
  408. Pingback: asics kayano 19
  409. Pingback: ugg boots
  410. Pingback: ugg pas cher
  411. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  412. Pingback: cheap asics
  413. Pingback: Michael Kors Bags
  414. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  415. Pingback: ugg soldes
  416. Pingback: Columbia 4s
  417. Pingback: cheap asics
  418. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  419. Pingback: asics gore tex
  420. Pingback: mens asics
  421. Pingback: nimbus asics
  422. Pingback: hare 7s
  423. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  424. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  425. Pingback: Louis Vuitton Sale
  426. Pingback: mens asics
  427. Pingback: asics noosa tri 9
  428. Pingback: jordan 11 72-10
  429. Pingback: retro jordans
  430. Pingback: jordan 11 low bred
  431. Pingback: threepeat 8s
  432. Pingback: nike air max zero
  433. Pingback: cheap ray bans
  434. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  435. Pingback: asics gore tex
  436. Pingback: jordan 11 72-10
  437. Pingback: new jordans
  438. Pingback: cheap jordan shoes
  439. Pingback: enigmaltd.com/
  440. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  441. Pingback: 72-10 11s
  442. Pingback: 60(OFF
  443. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  444. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 5
  445. Pingback: jordan 11
  446. Pingback: nike air zero
  447. Pingback: mens asics
  448. Pingback: 販売用品
  449. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  450. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  451. Pingback: 60>OFF
  452. Pingback: 最大70%割引
  453. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  454. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  455. Pingback: 60DOFF
  456. Pingback: 75%節約
  457. Pingback: 消費税なし
  458. Pingback: jordan 11 Low Bred
  459. Pingback: 適切な選択
  460. Pingback: Toms Sko storrelse
  461. Pingback: toms shoes online
  462. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  463. Pingback: mens asics
  464. Pingback: 壁一面値
  465. Pingback: buy wow gold
  466. Pingback: Cheap Red Bottoms
  467. Pingback: cheap new balance
  468. Pingback: urban camo asics
  469. Pingback: Occhiali da sole
  470. Pingback: amazon asics
  471. Pingback: asic nimbus 14
  472. Pingback: Occhiali Oakley
  473. Pingback: toms norge salg
  474. Pingback: サプライヤー
  475. Pingback: Hogan Italia
  476. Pingback: 送料無料
  477. Pingback: 60GOFF
  478. Pingback: asics nimbus 14
  479. Pingback: ucuz new balance
  480. Pingback: cheap jordans
  481. Pingback: nc press brake
  482. Pingback: nike free run 5
  483. Pingback: 最大70%割引
  484. Pingback: アウトレット
  485. Pingback: oaklye italia
  486. Pingback: camiseta tailandia
  487. Pingback: asics brasil
  488. Pingback: Orando City
  489. Pingback: asics 2170 mens
  490. Pingback: asics gt 2170 mens
  491. Pingback: buy Low Bred 11s
  492. Pingback: Contáctenos
  493. Pingback: nike free training
  494. Pingback: New York Cosmos
  495. Pingback: nba c 3
  496. Pingback: Occhiali
  497. Pingback: cheap air max 2015
  498. Pingback: asics 2170 womens
  499. Pingback: occhiali da sole
  500. Pingback: chanel 人気 靴
  501. Pingback: asics kinsei 4
  502. Pingback: cheap air max 90
  503. Pingback: asics urban camo
  504. Pingback: niños c 112
  505. Pingback: Low Bred 11s
  506. Pingback: asics nimbus 13
  507. Pingback: Stoke City
  508. Pingback: oakley sticker
  509. Pingback: vintage ray ban
  510. Pingback: camiseta Escocia
  511. Pingback: reviews
  512. Pingback: asics gore tex
  513. Pingback: Low Bred 11s 2015
  514. Pingback: Condiciones de uso
  515. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  516. Pingback: cheap nike air max
  517. Pingback: Low Bred 11s
  518. Pingback: asics cumulus 14
  519. Pingback: camiseta alemania
  520. Pingback: グッチ 本物
  521. Pingback: miumiu 財布
  522. Pingback: prada 財布
  523. Pingback: cheap new balance
  524. Pingback: celine 傘 激安
  525. Pingback: camiseta Rusia
  526. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  527. Pingback: cheap nike air max
  528. Pingback: Liga Turca
  529. Pingback: air max store
  530. Pingback: cheap asics
  531. Pingback: asics kayano 20
  532. Pingback: Nike Air Max 24
  533. Pingback: nimbus asics
  534. Pingback: asics gt 2170
  535. Pingback: プラダ 財布
  536. Pingback: 激安シャネル
  537. Pingback: burberry 鞄財布
  538. Pingback: Oakley Pit Bull
  539. Pingback: nike運動背包
  540. Pingback: adidas外套2015
  541. Pingback: jordan正版
  542. Pingback: nike白色球鞋
  543. Pingback: Nike Air Max 24
  544. Pingback: Toms Sko pa nett
  545. Pingback: asics 運動鞋
  546. Pingback: Toms Sko salg
  547. Pingback: nike lunarelite
  548. Pingback: toms Sko online
  549. Pingback: Toms norge l氓ven
  550. Pingback: Toms Sko
  551. Pingback: Toms Sko Kvadrat
  552. Pingback: Toms Sko Kvadrat
  553. Pingback: toms for Sko
  554. Pingback: jordan 13 bred
  555. Pingback: nike basketball uk
  556. Pingback: birkenstock shops
  557. Pingback: jordan 13 Low Bred
  558. Pingback: nike有氧鞋
  559. Pingback: toms barnesko
  560. Pingback: 4.0 flyknit
  561. Pingback: toms Sko utl酶p
  562. Pingback: Toms Sko
  563. Pingback: toms Sko 2015
  564. Pingback: 運動鞋帶
  565. Pingback: ジョーダン5
  566. Pingback: 韓國拍賣網站
  567. Pingback: 101鞋網
  568. Pingback: Oakley HIJINX
  569. Pingback: nike free black
  570. Pingback: miumiu 長財布
  571. Pingback: nike女慢跑鞋
  572. Pingback: 平底鞋 女
  573. Pingback: 走路鞋
  574. Pingback: Tory Burch 日傘
  575. Pingback: 平價慢跑鞋
  576. Pingback: outlet air max
  577. Pingback: nike free.com
  578. Pingback: outlet air max
  579. Pingback: nike air max tr
  580. Pingback: outlet air max
  581. Pingback: 跑步 包包
  582. Pingback: 慢跑長褲
  583. Pingback: chanel激安財布
  584. Pingback: hogan outlet
  585. Pingback: グッチ ズー
  586. Pingback: outlet hogan
  587. Pingback: hogan outlet
  588. Pingback: Oakley Jury
  589. Pingback: 運動衣 女
  590. Pingback: outlet hogan
  591. Pingback: コーチ 時計
  592. Pingback: グッチ 煮卵
  593. Pingback: outlet air max
  594. Pingback: oakley outlet
  595. Pingback: jordan 11代女鞋
  596. Pingback: nike透氣鞋
  597. Pingback: outlet oakley
  598. Pingback: adidas鞋子尺寸
  599. Pingback: oakley occhiali
  600. Pingback: nike acg 外套
  601. Pingback: 全氣墊慢跑鞋
  602. Pingback: occhiali oakley
  603. Pingback: roshe boys
  604. Pingback: oakley occhiali
  605. Pingback: nike馬拉松鞋
  606. Pingback: outlet oakley
  607. Pingback: occhiali oakley
  608. Pingback: air jordan xi
  609. Pingback: outlet oakley
  610. Pingback: oakley occhiali
  611. Pingback: oakley occhiali
  612. Pingback: 最新鞋款
  613. Pingback: 運動衫
  614. Pingback: Gorro YMCMB [Negro
  615. Pingback: chanel新作財布
  616. Pingback: occhiali oakley
  617. Pingback: Luckys Oakley Ca
  618. Pingback: pay4you
  619. Pingback: Nike Air Max 24
  620. Pingback: dunk sb
  621. Pingback: order toms shoes
  622. Pingback: outlet oakley
  623. Pingback: nike uk.com
  624. Pingback: Oakley Number
  625. Pingback: Oakley HOLBROOK
  626. Pingback: Oakley FLAK JACKET
  627. Pingback: cheapest nike free
  628. Pingback: グッチ 安く
  629. Pingback: 短褲 鞋子
  630. Pingback: Holbrooks Oakleys
  631. Pingback: 網路購鞋
  632. Pingback: 鳥巢拖鞋
  633. Pingback: Oakley Packs
  634. Pingback: 跑步鞋推薦
  635. Pingback: 真皮靴保養
  636. Pingback: グッチ 緑 赤
  637. Pingback: Oakley Crew Shoes
  638. Pingback: Oakley Wikipedia
  639. Pingback: Nike Air Max 24
  640. Pingback: Clearance Oakleys
  641. Pingback: Oakley Golf Polos
  642. Pingback: chanel激安店
  643. Pingback: 帆布休閒鞋
  644. Pingback: Radar Range Oakley
  645. Pingback: outlet oakley
  646. Pingback: oakley outlet
  647. Pingback: imirroor健走鞋
  648. Pingback: 踝靴
  649. Pingback: outlet air max
  650. Pingback: outlet air max
  651. Pingback: toms 店
  652. Pingback: 運動休閒服
  653. Pingback: chanel最新財布
  654. Pingback: Oakley Watch Case
  655. Pingback: prada 財布 2015
  656. Pingback: occhiali oakley
  657. Pingback: グッチ 中古
  658. Pingback: 足球鞋
  659. Pingback: nike鞋 黑白
  660. Pingback: oakley ソック
  661. Pingback: occhiali oakley
  662. Pingback: 內增高 nike
  663. Pingback: nike air max usa
  664. Pingback: nike roshe womens
  665. Pingback: outlet air max
  666. Pingback: 男士短褲
  667. Pingback: Oakley Pd
  668. Pingback: nike 眼鏡
  669. Pingback: 流行包
  670. Pingback: nike mercurial ii
  671. Pingback: nike free ireland
  672. Pingback: Oakley Mx
  673. Pingback: nike air max blue
  674. Pingback: Oakley S
  675. Pingback: Nike Air Max 24
  676. Pingback: 鞋子女
  677. Pingback: oakley occhiali
  678. Pingback: Nike Air Max 24
  679. Pingback: Oakley Grapevine
  680. Pingback: buy jordan
  681. Pingback: 偽物chanel財布
  682. Pingback: flyknit 開箱
  683. Pingback: Oakley Radar Cheap
  684. Pingback: raptor 7
  685. Pingback: Belstaff Outlet UK
  686. Pingback: Oakley A Frames
  687. Pingback: Oakley Owner
  688. Pingback: bred 4s for sale
  689. Pingback: buy jordan retro 7
  690. Pingback: nike free 50
  691. Pingback: nike air max tn 1
  692. Pingback: roshe youth
  693. Pingback: son of mars
  694. Pingback: nike blazers gray
  695. Pingback: nike free run buy
  696. Pingback: Oakley L Frame
  697. Pingback: jordan 11 low aqua
  698. Pingback: chanel 財布
  699. Pingback: Tory Burch 海外
  700. Pingback: 渋谷 Tory Burch
  701. Pingback: jordan for cheap
  702. Pingback: ray ban b&l precio
  703. Pingback: nike shoes uk
  704. Pingback: Tory Burch 赤
  705. Pingback: jordan 11 low
  706. Pingback: Oakley Closeout
  707. Pingback: nike blazers gray
  708. Pingback: new balance 475
  709. Pingback: nike air max wavy
  710. Pingback: store.nike.co uk
  711. Pingback: Oakley Split Thump
  712. Pingback: Oakley Thump 256
  713. Pingback: Oakley Script
  714. Pingback: nike free run blue
  715. Pingback: purple dresses uk
  716. Pingback: Knockoff Oakleys
  717. Pingback: Oakley Travel Bag
  718. Pingback: roshe youth
  719. Pingback: hologram 13s
  720. Pingback: nike air max i
  721. Pingback: